A
Literary Saloon
&
Site of Review.

Trying to meet all your book preview and review needs.



Contents:
Main
the Best
the Rest
Review Index
Links

weblog

crQ

RSS

to e-mail us:


support the site



In Association with Amazon.com


In association with Amazon.com - UK


In association with Amazon.ca - Canada


In 
Partnerschaft 
mit 
Amazon.de


En 
partenariat 
avec 
amazon.fr

the Complete Review
the complete review - fiction

     

Tirza

by
Arnon Grunberg


general information | review summaries | our review | links | about the author

To purchase Tirza



Title: Tirza
Author: Arnon Grunberg
Genre: Novel
Written: 2006
Length: 432 pages
Original in: Dutch
Availability: Tirza - US
Tirza - UK
Tirza - Canada
Tirza - France
Tirza - India
Tirza - Deutschland
Il maestro di cerimonie - Italia
  • Dutch title: Tirza
  • Translated by Sam Garrett
  • Tirza was made into a film in 2010, directed by Rudolf van den Berg and starring Gijs Scholten van Aschat and Sylvia Hoeks

- Return to top of the page -



Our Assessment:

A : exceptional study of a man losing all hold in life

See our review for fuller assessment.




Review Summaries
Source Rating Date Reviewer
Le Figaro . 26/11/2009 Johanna Luyssen
FAZ . 8/5/2008 Maria Frisé
The LA Times . 11/4/2013 Jacob Silverman
The NY Times Book Rev. . 12/5/2013 Scott Hutchins
NRC Handelsblad . 10/11/2006 Annelies Verbeke
Publishers Weekly . 11/2/2013 .
De Standaard . 22/9/2006 Matthijs de Ridder
Die Welt . 5/4/2008 Hendrik Werner


  From the Reviews:
  • "Arnon Grunberg chronique les errements d'une bourgeoisie flamande morose, et construit un thriller psychologique délectable." - Johanna Luyssen, Le Figaro

  • "(I)n Tirza, seinem jüngsten Roman, überspannt Grünberg den Bogen. Oder wollte er einen Psychothriller produzieren, als er den bedauernswerten, etwas trottligen Vater der lieblichen Tirza in einen Wüstling verwandelte ?" - Maria Frisé, Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung

  • "Tirza is a rather sober novel, but it's a formidable work. (...) In the novel's last section, set in Namibia where Tirza is traveling with her boyfriend, Hofmeester goes in search of his daughter, as he hopes to make one last stand against this dangerous world, one supreme effort to justify his quiet sacrifice. Grunberg laces this section with a stunning twist; it erupts before the reader with the sudden torque and violence of a land mine." - Jacob Silverman, The Los Angeles Times

  • "Tirza, the sixth of Grunberg’s novels translated into English, is grimly comic and unflinching. While not always enjoyable, it is never less than enthralling. (...) Much fun is had with this rigid adherence to sexual permissiveness, but the satire is not antic. Hofmeester is a subdued guide, ratcheted to his breaking point." - Scott Hutchins, The New York Times Book Review

  • "Tirza is een roman die elke schrijver had willen schrijven, al zullen velen beweren dat ik enkel voor mezelf mag spreken." - Annelies Verbeke, NRC Handelsblad

  • "Grunberg's lengthy narrative flows through Hofmeester's obsessive and painstaking attention to superfluous detail, but the story never falls flat, unraveling with humor and poignancy until the end." - Publishers Weekly

  • "Wat Tirza tot een grote roman maakt, is de uitgebalanceerde compositie. Elk woord meer dat wordt gespendeerd aan de loop van het verhaal, verpest het leesplezier voor eenieder die zich wil laten verrassen door de lang verstopte plot. Maar er schuilt een nog veel gevaarlijker schoonheid in het boek en dat is de alledaagsheid, die oer-Nederlandse, die doodgewone westerse levenshouding, die de voedingsbodem blijkt te zijn voor een totaal verknipte maatschappij in de wereld zonder Twin Towers." - Matthijs de Ridder, De Standaard

  • "Grünberg beschreibt mit dramaturgischer Souveränität und maßvollem Witz die Geschichte eines schleichenden Verfalls. Der Hauptfigur laufen Besitzstände, Gewissheiten und die Zeit davon. Wie sie sich aus dieser Beklemmung zu lösen versucht, ist kaum glaublich. Und gerade darum absolut lesenswert." - Hendrik Werner, Die Welt

Please note that these ratings solely represent the complete review's biased interpretation and subjective opinion of the actual reviews and do not claim to accurately reflect or represent the views of the reviewers. Similarly the illustrative quotes chosen here are merely those the complete review subjectively believes represent the tenor and judgment of the review as a whole. We acknowledge (and remind and warn you) that they may, in fact, be entirely unrepresentative of the actual reviews by any other measure.

- Return to top of the page -



The complete review's Review:

       Tirza tells the story of Jörgen Hofmeester, a middle-aged man put out to pasture who is about to lose the last thing that gives his pathetic life any meaning any longer, his younger daughter Tirza, who is set to embark for Africa after graduating from high school. The long novel covers a relatively short time span, with some two-thirds of it devoted to the evening on which Tirza's graduation-party is held at the Hofmeester house, described in painful, painstaking detail by Grunberg. Few authors are as adept at moment-by-moment descriptions and (generally awkward) human interaction as Grunberg and in this novel he contains himself (unlike, for example, The Jewish Messiah, where he eventually runs amok), to quite stunning (and also disturbing) effect.
       As Hofmeester arranges things -- from his special cocktails to home-made sushi -- and waits and waits, and then as the party itself gets rolling, Grunberg fills in the details of family life and history -- sticking closely always to his hapless, hopeless protagonist. Things haven't been going his way for a while. Hofmeester's wife abandoned him and the two girls, Ibi and Tirza, three years earlier, for an old flame, but she returned to the fold a few days before the party -- an unexpected and not much wanted guest, but baffled Hofmeester, who didn't know what to do when she left certainly doesn't know what to do now that she's back. Ibi has also long since flown the coop, though she shows up for the party too; this older daughter eluded Hofmeester early on (when he found her, still only fourteen, giving herself up to the upstairs tenant (who wasn't her first) -- which he couldn't recognize or accept as a sign that maybe something was desperately wrong in the Hofmeester household).
       Hofmeester has been saving up his money -- putting some aside in a foreign bank account, making investments. He actually amassed a million, but then took up the bank's suggestion and invested it all in a hedge fund, and then all that money wasn't there any longer. He is still fairly well off, but his dreams of making his daughters' -- and especially Tirza's -- lives easier have been shattered.
       Hofmeester has spent his life working as an editor -- specializing in foreign literature -- for a book publisher, but they've grown tired of him. They'd fire him if they could, but the labor laws make that impossible. But he is so dispensable that they just tell him to go home: they'll continue paying him until his official retirement, but for now they'd rather he didn't actually do any more work. Unwilling to admit his professional failure to anyone, he develops a new routine of commuting to Schiphol airport, and puttering around there for the day .....
       The one light of his life, the one person who depends on him and whom he is devoted to, is darling Tirza. Exceptionally gifted, he always called her -- until it turned out that maybe he was putting too much pressure on her, with his demanding schedule of cello-playing and swimming, and bedtime reading of Tolstoy, leading to her getting an eating disorder. In a rare moment of actually taking the incentive he does the right thing to help her there -- but he's incapable of being entirely the kind of father-figure she needs. Still, the two get along and have a strange but affectionate relationship, convincingly conveyed by Grunberg.
       But Hofmeester is about to lose this one, last hold. Tirza has her heart set on going to Africa before she begins her studies. This party is pretty much her farewell.
       Tirza also plans to go with her boyfriend, whom her father has never met. Tirza often brought boys home, even for the night, but this is more serious.
       The party begins with Tirza off somewhere picking up her boyfriend, and things are already long underway by the time they arrive. It's no surprise that Hofmeester doesn't take to the guy taking away his little princess, but when he sees the guy he nearly cracks: he thinks Choukri is the spitting image of September, 2001 terrorist Mohammed Atta (whom he also blames for the collapse of the hedge fund with all his savings). Indeed, that's how Hofmeester continues to refer to her daughter's boyfriend.
       Things don't go well at the party, but for the most part it just amounts to minor party catastrophes. And afterwards Hofmeester continues to clutch at straws -- and tries, in his own way, to come to grips with everything. In his misguided efforts he even offers to drive the couple to the Frankfurt airport for their flight, stopping off in their vacation home for the weekend first .....
       Hofmeester does try, but he's constantly losing his grip. After he returns home from the weekend expedition he can't leave be, and insists on following the couple: he flies down to Namibia, to follow their trail. His misadventures there verge on the uncomfortably grotesque, yet Hofmeester's sins are not those that everyone he encounters assumes: for once he does some good, and manages, briefly, to provide comfort. But he doesn't find Tirza and Choukri.
       Grunberg very adroitly reveals what has happened, in a devastating twist that you wouldn't think could be pulled off. Hapless Hofmeester turns out to be both a much better man, and a much worse one, than he seemed. But the cascade of events took a terrible wrong turn, and out of it comes complete ruin; Tirza is completely heartbreaking.
       In his youth Hofmeester toyed with the idea of doing away with love -- a concept as outmoded as god, he thought. Love certainly failed him, beginning with the woman he picked to be his wife, entirely wrong for him. He could and did love his daughters, but it overwhelmed them: Ibi escaped as soon as she could, but Tirza remained close enough for some sort of lasting (if often uneasy), semi-happy relationship to be maintained. But then Tirza, too, wanted to stake out her independence, and Hofmeester was incapable of handling it.
       Grunberg gives Hofmeester an opportunity for redemption, of sorts, but redemption does not come easy. Hofmeester tries, again, but just leaves another shattered soul in his wake. It's never for want of trying that he can't find or hold onto love; as well-meaning as he can be, it's simply not in him to do it right.
       Hofmeester is not a particularly sympathetic character, but his flaws are human and plausible; so too are, in his desperation, his actions, even as they go beyond the bounds of acceptable behavior. Grunberg's penetrating character study is no pleasant tale (though there is a good deal of humor in it too), but, in its horrifying inevitability (and Grunberg's willingness to allow his character to plunge without finding any hold) absolutely compelling.
       The action in Tirza takes place within a relatively short time-frame, and in it Grunberg captures perfectly what has become of this man, and how he got to this point. It is not always an agreeable read, but an exceptional one.

- M.A.Orthofer, 1 September 2009

- Return to top of the page -



Links:

Tirza: Reviews: Tirza - the film: Arnon Grunberg: Other books by Arnon Grunberg under review: Other books of interest under review:
  • See Index of Dutch literature at the complete review

- Return to top of the page -



About the Author:

       Dutch author Arnon Grunberg was born in 1971 and has won numerous literary prizes.

- Return to top of the page -


© 2009-2014 the complete review

Main | the New | the Best | the Rest | Review Index | Links